Government-Supported Religion

Ben Carson Has No Idea What Separation Of Church And State Means

  Rob Boston

Secretary of Housing and Urban Development Ben Carson raised a few eyebrows earlier this week when he referenced separation of church and state during an opening prayer before a cabinet meeting.

During the prayer, Carson thanked God for President Donald Trump, adding that he appreciates Trump’s advisers who “help us all to recognize as a nation that separation of church and state means that the church does not dominate the state, and it means the state does not dominate the church.”

That part’s not so bad, but Carson followed with this: “It doesn’t mean that they cannot work together to promote godly principles.”

Well, no, it means exactly that. For the government to take on the task of promoting “godly principles,” it would first have to determine what’s godly and what’s not. It would have to elevate one version of faith over others and never be neutral on matters of theology. That sort of thing might fly in the Republic of Gilead but not here. Nothing could be more dangerous.

Furthermore, this administration has an appalling record on separation of religion and government. As Americans United President and CEO Rachel Laser told the Associated Press, Carson’s remark is “hypocritical and does a disservice to this constitutional principle.”

Added Laser, “Church-state separation means that all Americans have the right to believe or not, as long as they don’t harm others. This administration’s policies and rhetoric, by contrast, privilege a narrow set of religious views above all others.”

Laser’s comments appeared in newspapers and online news nationwide. It was the third time in recent weeks that AU has taken on Trump administration officials for trashing church-state separation. AU criticized Attorney General William Barr for delivering an appalling talk assailing secular government at the University of Notre Dame Oct. 11. The same day, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo gave a proselytizing speech on “Being a Christian Leader” to an audience in Tennessee. Americans United has requested that the department’s Inspector General’s Office investigate the talk.

It’s probably no coincidence that this administration, which is under scrutiny for a growing scandal that threatens to culminate in Trump’s impeachment, is desperately trying to bury its misdeeds under a cloak of religiosity. But Carson and his fellow Trump travelers have forgotten one important thing: that church-state separation is a real, vital constitutional principle – one that rebukes them at every turn.

P.S. Christian nationalists may not like it, but Americans United intends to keep on challenging every violation of church-state separation by this administration. We’d appreciate your support.

Photo: White House shot of Trump cabinet meeting from 2018.



Americans United & the National Women’s Law Center file suit to challenge Missouri’s abortion bans.

Abortion bans violate the separation of church and state. Americans United and the National Women’s Law Center—the leading experts in religious freedom and gender justice—have joined forces with thirteen clergy from six faith traditions to challenge Missouri’s abortion bans as unconstitutionally imposing one narrow religious doctrine on everyone.

Join the Fight and Donate Today