January 2019 Church & State - January 2019

Trump Administration Works To Scuttle Pro-LGBTQ Policy In 4-H Programs

  Rob Boston

The Trump-Pence administration’s animus against LGBTQ people is so strong it has even infiltrated the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and is affecting a program aimed at young people who are interested in farming.

A November report by the Des Moines Register exposed how officials in the USDA helped to deep-six a more inclusive LGBTQ policy proposed by 4-H, an international organization known for encouraging children’s interest in farming and animal husbandry.

As part of a broader, long-term initiative to diversify the federally subsidized organization, 4-H leadership earlier this year drafted a new guidance intended to ensure that LGBTQ children feel welcome and protected in the organization. But once several state 4-H chapters posted the proposed guidance on their websites to seek public comment, conservative Christian groups began to protest. They were particularly up in arms about a recommendation stating that transgender 4-H members should be treated in accordance with their gender identity.

A Religious Right group in Iowa called The Family Leader labeled the guidance “radical” and resorted to fear-mongering, with a representative claiming the changes would encourage pedophilia. The Religious Right legal firm Liberty Counsel wrote to Iowa State University, which oversees Iowa’s 4-H program, and threatened unspecified “additional action” if the policy was not terminated.

According to the Register’s report, days after the 4-H guidance was published online, a chief of staff for U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue requested that it be rescinded, and a communications manager for the USDA’s National Institute of Food and Agriculture – the federal department that administers 4-H – emailed at least two state 4-H offices telling them to remove the LGBTQ guidance from their websites.

“The subsequent decision to take down the policy set off a firestorm this spring that engulfed 4-H programs in at least eight states – including Iowa, Idaho, Wisconsin, California, Oregon, Nevada, Colorado, Virginia and New York,” the Register reported. It also led to the firing of Iowa’s 4-H director, a strong advocate of the LGBTQ policy.

The fired official, John-Paul Chaisson-Cárdenas, resisted efforts to remove the policy, arguing that 4-H is “for all kids.” Chaisson-Cárdenas also reported receiving death threats.

The proposed guidance called on 4-H leaders to treat all children taking part in a manner consistent with their gender identity, and said they should receive equal access to programs and activities even if others complained.

The Register reported that while some people involved in 4-H applauded the changes in favor of LGBTQ tolerance, others pushed back strongly and sent messages to the 4-H leader in Iowa calling the guidance a “fascist push to redefine humanity” and calling transgender children “horrendous” and “sinful.”

After the guidance was removed from 4-H websites, USDA officials issued a terse statement saying it was never official policy.

Chaisson-Cárdenas said he doesn’t regret standing up for LGBTQ kids.

“I’m paying a very heavy price for doing it, and I don’t regret it for a single second,” he told the Register. “It was the right thing to do.”

Not on our watch, Governor Landry!

Help AU fight Christian Nationalism in Louisiana

Louisiana's new Ten Commandments Law violates the separation of church and state and is blatantly unconstitutional. Politicians have no business imposing their preferred religious doctrine on students and families in public schools.

Join the fight